ISSN: 2822-552X
Examining the relationship between design guidelines and user practices in the context of aging in place
1Faculty of Architecture, Yıldız Technical University, İstanbul, Türkiye
Recent Advances in Science and Engineering 21-30 DOI: 10.14744/rase.2026.0003
Full Text PDF

Abstract

Aging in place policies, which have emerged as a global priority due to population aging, are primarily spatialized through normative design guidelines that provide universal physical standards. However, this approach tends to reduce the dwelling to a purely medicalized shelter, thereby marginalizing the dimension of sociocultural belonging. Addressing this problem, the present study aims to reveal the empirical discrepancies between normative standards and actual user practices. To this end, 10 normative guidelines and 43 field studies across 14 countries were analyzed using a thematic meta-synthesis method. The findings indicate that while themes of safety and accessibility demonstrate consistency across diverse contexts, vital culturally specific dimensions, such as familial care, privacy, balcony usage, and spatial memory, remain largely underrepresented within the evaluative scope of these guidelines. Relying solely on these guidelines in the design process, despite their legitimacy in ensuring minimum physical standards, leads to significant experiential deficiencies in the
living environment. Ultimately, this study highlights the critical need for a complementary model that integrates physical metrics with sociocultural practices.